Plasma wayland vs full wayland. I only like to boot system once in a weak.

Plasma wayland vs full wayland Org Xfce X. If you're sensitive to low input lag, well, stock Plasma Wayland isn't for you. However, KDE plasma on wayland is still not working on my GeForce RTX 2060 (with the proprietary nvidia (kernel) drivers from akmod-nvidia and xorg-x11-drv-nvidia). So I exited my login session (I switched to a text-based session manager, ly, to see if it would make things easier) and all of the sudden the VM I tried to start earlier booted right up! It's largely a matter of where your priorities lie. This article should give a better idea on what to expect in this regard: and last session was selected explicitly at SDDM login screen (logout, make sure to select Plasma Wayland, login then reboot). g. Thanks! I don't know about the technical considerations, but if this is the reason that none of the sessions work 'out of the box' with multiple displays for me, then I am with the Plasma developers. However do note if your using Wayland, not all apps run in Wayland mode, but in Xwayland. My guess is that because the Wayland session comes first in the list of sessions to choose from with a new installation, if the user Wayland is lean in comparison, this shows in CPU usage of Xorg versus kwin_wayland. And it keeps getting more stable every release. Reply reply Wayland is the future so as time goes by more features will be wayland only, right now there's already some wayland only features, such as a mouse scrolling speed option, a applet that shows you whenever you're screen sharing and a screen recording applet (not sure if the latter was merged though) After I login with sddm the desktop will appear temporarily, then after a few seconds the screen will go completely black (no cursor or anything else) and remain black. I'm using it in 5. Whereas Plasma in "Full Wayland" mode outputs directly to Wayland which has much more risks/problems since it relies on KDE's internal wayland compositor. Maybe the font DPI setting is causing the difference? In any case, what you are seeing in your Wayland screenshot seems to be what 100% scale actually is supposed to look like. Since 5. 0 or the GNOME X11 session. Testing a full Plasma Session. Is there any Hello, I’m not seeing anyone else having this issue. A display server using the Wayland protocol is called a Wayland compositor, because it additionally performs the task of a compositing window manager. The monitor in question: 2560x1440 @ 165 Hz over DisplayPort. Visit the KDE MetaStore. And these options are duplicated for any custom session installed on the system (e. From what I understand, Plasma 6 is supposed to include substantial improvement for fractional scaling on Wayland. My system crashes when I try to log in from sddm (i. EOS newbie here, i have been using EOS for over a year and have just now come to an issue. I have been using Ubuntu (with Unity and Gnome desktops) and later KDE (with Plasma) for many years on X for everyday academic work, and switched to Wayland when Plasma 6 was released earlier this year. ” “The Plasma Wayland session has now gained support for feature Y. If you are on X11 and don’t find Wayland session at the login screen, you probably don’t have it installed. I have been using KDE Plasma Wayland for a couple of years now, Posted: Tue Oct 01, 2024 2:35 pm Post subject: Re: Plasma Wayland vs X11 auto login: Progman3K wrote: Hi, If I log out and select Plasma X-11 instead of Wayland, and log back in, then every time I go to the SDDM login menu, Plasma X-11 is set as default. 0 Kernel Version: 6. Browse Plasma 6 vs Cinnamon 6 . This is because the XWayland layer present on Plasma ( wayland ) I am actually not sure where they are getting Wayland vs Full Wayland, unless it's a option the Distro added in. The monitor appears to still receive signal. conf set: I have an Arch desktop PC with X11+KDE Plasma and I'd like to switch it to Wayland, mostly for security reasons. It also contains a command-line based server which will allow remote clients to control the current Plasma Wayland Unfortunate. kinfo Operating System: CachyOS Linux KDE Plasma Version: 6. Install the plasma-meta meta-package or the plasma group. Some of the bugs are just so random that I have no idea how they get triggered Clipboard issues and those weird little bugs you may or may not get occasionally in Plasma, plus various multi monitor bugs, are why my main PC isn't on Wayland yet (oh, and I miss gamma control on Wayland as a gamma of 1. reading and hijacking inputs), leaving any mitigations fully on the application's side. If I had to take a random guess, I assume one probably utilizes xwayland for most of the Plasma Session and one utilizes the the actual wayland implementation. I'm gonna try disabling the compositor out right in wayland, because I upgraded to Fedora 35 yesterday. It was a mighty fine year for the Wayland ecosystem on the Linux desktop with KDE Plasma 6 having brought much more polished Wayland support and now at parity to its X11 session, the NVIDIA driver stack seeing much better Wayland support with its latest drivers, LXQt and Xfce and others working more on Wayland support, and the continued climb of various Don’t know if I can explain this properly but I will try. r. Fedora 37 plans to make SDDM Wayland by default. I agree with the rest of your points. It’s still not standard. I'm sure that you can realize that it is full of informations and it's hard to understand why nothing happens to me Plasma (Full wayland) is the bare Wayland display protocol, without the aforementioned compatibility layer Takeaway: Plasma (wayland) trades performances in favour of compatibility, and vice-versa for Plasma (Full wayland). I'm still looking for a good tutorial to learn how to configure FreeBSD to try it. patch to not When I wrote about Wayland on FreeBSD I did not expect it to trigger “remove Wayland” kinds of comments in FreeBSD ports. AMDGPU and wayland are default for me for 1 year or so. During the fresh KDE install I did not notice a Wayland option and proceeded with X11. X. I’m not very versed in linux but love to learn new things. It took over I'm using the Nvidia driver and I've installed KDE Plasma with SDDM, along with the Wayland dependencies for Plasma with Nvidia (plasma-wayland-session, egl-wayland). 04 with the latest KDE Plasma from the backports PPA and haven't seen much issues with my Intel GPU. 23 was the first release where the Plasma Wayland session became broadly usable. Under Wayland this was non-existent and everything happened at a reasonable speed. Org KDE Plasma Wayland KDE Plasma X. I also had those issues when switching between wayland and X11 without rebooting. This is part of KDE's Wayland goal. LXQt has Wayland now and it isn't provisional or experimental but I don't know how well it works. So, that completes the KDE Plasma setup with Wayland in Arch Linux. Im using Kubuntu 22. 10 Wayland, and now I'm on Manjaro KDE Plasma 6 Wayland. But plasma x11 breaks every 2days or 3days. 0 gaming performance between I don't know what's going on with the scaling. Full screen video works great, transparency is perfect (e. Like, one of the non-subjective things I can replicate is panel icon drag & drop being quirky. If I had to take a random guess, I assume one probably utilizes Wayland (the protocol) is 13 years old, the Plasma Wayland session was first released 6 years ago. 11 Beta 1 and this will come with an interesting new feature: an experimental Wayland backend inside KWin. Eventually that became "The protocol is ready to use! I also have no issues with plasma on wayland. Just tried that and yup. This one’s been dead for almost a As the KDE team continue working full steam ahead towards Plasma 6, they're now down to a single showstopping bug for having Wayland by default. Anything else, I'd definitely run X11 sessions even if I've literally never had a better linux experience than AMD + Wayland + KDE Plasma. KDE. Wayland: Wayland takes a more modern approach, employing a simpler architecture that aims to eliminate the complexities of X11. Since this is always some Electron shitware I installed using Flatpak, I add GDK_BACKEND=x11 to their environment overrides to fix this by letting them run on XWayland. 27K subscribers in the openSUSE community. I want to use XWayland, since my previous installation of Fedora Workstation did not ever produce blurry graphics even when Wayland was enabled. Overall, the KDE Plasma in Wayland with Arch Linux works well. Wayland support in the KDE Plasma Workspaces is in a tech-preview state. KDE Plasma should use X11 according to Tested's video. 165Hz is Overall the KDE Plasma 6. @omano @AlexBoldt what has changed with the new ISOs is that plasma-wayland-session is installed now by default and that gives you the option to choose between Wayland and X11 on the logon screen (lower left corner). Anything. I have played around Plasma last year but never made the full transition. That is amazing progress by any metric, and I won't have it erased. CPU: Ryzen 9 5900X. mkey82 (Marko K) As the topic title states, when running full screen applications (players, games, even browser media players) the screen will intermittently go black for a second or two. I created the two files under sddm. What works and what doesn’t work. 21 X11 to Wayland kde, kde-plasma, wayland, audio, nvidia. zero problems whatsoever. However, here is the problem. In VirtualBox, a Plasma Wayland session essentially gives me a full-screen resolution inside the host’s VirtualBox window, but with X11, the resolution max’s out at 1440x900 (the same as with my OpenMandriva Xfce VirtualBoxes) . org/KWin Much also depends on if you're a "glass half empty" or "glass half full" sort of person. 0 will release. 10 with plasma 5. Wayland has a few benefits generally. But it didn't do that in 5. I wish there was a First off I think I got bit by a partial update or potential conflict (still looking into it). 40GHz Depending on what hardware is utilized the most (CPU or GPU) Wayland can be a mixed bag, (example: VAAPI). Starting a full KDE Plasma session in Wayland. Last I checked there's no way to disable compositing on Plasma Wayland so there's forced vsync on fullscreen games even with VRR enabled. I installed what is suggested on the wiki. 6. What are the issues with X11 and why is Wayland better? What are the technological advantages and most importantly, how will this affect the end consumer? Plasma 5. On X11 there's lots of little cursor issues too, like "jumpy cursors" where scaling can be off for a split second, or the cursor outright changing to some internal X11 theme. The packet, iirc, is called plasma-wayland-session. so my display manager is now full wayland as well. Wayland latency is the one thing holding me back from switching to it full time. 0. Can anyone explain (maybe a link to docs?) what’s But when running Counter-Strike 2 at 4K for the full native resolution, the GNOME Wayland session saw a significant drop in performance compared to KDE Plasma 6. Nothing show-stopper or any For desktop, you can choose between Wayland and X11 in the lower left corner of SDDM. enabling/disabling Vsync, which has a direct impact on latency). (Gnome, however, is ready and is used on distros with Wayland by default, like Fedora and Ubuntu. I use KDE, and there is KDE X11 and KDE Wayland and both seem to have problem with them. I think the reason the option you're referring to isn't working is because it doesn't work with non-wayland native things right now, but I could be wrong on that. But it seems like it's something that's being worked on so there is hope. To keep up to date, I am listening to Linux Podcast (since I am now running Linux full time) and there seems to be some drama as far as Wayland vs X11. 1-RELEASE,but I'm not able to understand how much good it is at this point. But, video games should run through XWayland with the Gamescope Wayland compositor. 14 years of existing and basic things still don’t work, and everyone tries to convince us it’s better than X even though the evidence is right in front of whether or not it'll horribly break applications. The whole X11 vs. I am using SDDM. When the environment variables are not set explicitly, they default to wayland since several KDE Plasma versions ago. 8. If I try and boot one of the new Live ISOs Hey, Im using newly installed EndevourOS + KDE 6 + Wayland + Nvidia optimus (550 drivers) over DisplayPort. Afterwards, you can chose between wayland and x11 at login Note that, after switching to Wayland, there is now an option to choose between Wayland or X11 from the login screen: at the bottom-right corner, click the Settings icon, and choose GNOME on Xorg if you prefer to use X11. So you must have a separate As far as I know, Plasma only has 2 sessions. conf. 3, this is more general to KDE. every single release were told “Wayland is better now for real this time”, and yet it still fails at basic things and is full of bugs. kde. t. Is this the thread to list issues between using X11 and Wayland? Or should I start a new thread? Aragorn 7 September 2023 21:42 22. If I select a larger resolution for the X11 session, some aspects of the screen, including the panel, get chopped off. ) However, there is a project by Collabora to bring full Wayland support to WINE, which is Hi friends. Everything seems to work fine except a few visual glitches in certain applications such as IntelliJ IDEA. Wayland is now the new default. For compositors, a kernel supporting the evdev(4) driver must exist to utilize the keybinding functionality. I guess that it means GTK and Qt backends are set to using Wayland only (something which has taken a lot of development to do) +Wed Aug 28 13:23:28 UTC 2019 - Fabian Vogt <fabian@ritter-vogt. Show your love for KDE! Purchase books, mugs, apparel, and more to support KDE. Additionally, I can switch to a TTY and then back to the plasma session and then the desktop will sometimes reappear and then stay visible. M. ” And it’s in the news quite a bit lately with the announcement that Fedora KDE IMO testing on Plasma 6 right now is not testing Wayland vs X, it's testing a random assortment of unsquished bugs. The hack I implemened only does tearing in fullscreen i dont quite understand why it would break applications, i hope wayland-native apps do not depend on vsync on, or assume thats Plasma Wayland support is one of those things that, for me, always seems to be just behind the corner. Same deal though. Wayland, since OP's Ubuntu 22. This is because the XWayland layer present on Plasma (wayland) incurs some overhead in order to maximize compatibility. Wayland. It may offer some hints the required glue to create a server exposing a KDE Plasma Wayland session over the RDP protocol. . X11 Vs Wayland . Nvidia is still catching up but as someone else mentioned Fedora 36 + GNOME 42 with wayland on NV works surprisingly well, just don't expect VRR anytime soon because that doesn't work on either nvidia or GNOME Wayland. If I kill the plasma-wayland-protocols - Plasma Specific Protocols for Wayland qt5-wayland - Qt 5 Wayland Library wayland - Wayland is intended as a simpler replacement for X, easier to develop and maintain. If force low latency in the compositor it definitely helps, but X11 still feels more responsive IMO. In order to get Plasma to launch under Wayland, I had to disable the modules for my Ryzen CPU's IGPU, and also set the nvidia_drm. 1 GiB of RAM Graphics Processor: AMD You can test this theory by checking if the issue goes away when set to 100% or 200% scaling. Full fun. org. The first thing I noticed was various screen resolution issues. The aim of Wayland is replacing the X Window System (Also known as X11, or Xorg) with a modern, secure, and Wayland vs. For differences between plasma-meta and plasma reference Package group. Going based on latency tests here It acted kinda as a middle ground between the X11 session and the Full Wayland session as some X11 problems weren't there but OTOH some Wayland glitches were present. Capture full “journalctl -b” output after reboot into X11 autologin session and reboot into Wayland autologin session. American / Euro Truck Simulator opens on the wrong screen on Plasma Wayland and behaves very weirdly) A game has other issues with windowing / full screen / Alt+Tab An older game can't run at my display's native resolution so I use gamescope to upscale it and maybe apply FSR too With Wayland things are more complicated and the compositor cannot really be disabled completely as far as I understand, but KWin/Plasma Wayland will offer in the future manually-toggable optimizations (e. If OP's use cases refer to much fancy in X11, then OP can abandon Wayland simply and go with OP's beloved legacy X11 instead. If you care about security and tearfree graphics, use Wayland. I can start an X11 session just fine but Wayland starts to login in then restarts right back to the login screen. 2 KDE Frameworks Version: 6. I would like to try and test Wayland with KDE Plasma on FreeBSD 13. I think for a lot of home users, what has changed with the new ISOs is that plasma-wayland-session is installed now by default and that gives you the option to choose between Wayland and X11 on the Anyone talking about lack of KDE progress on Wayland has obviously not seen what Plasma Wayland was in early 2020 and what it is now. 4 KWin is able to manage Wayland clients and this allows to start a Plasma session on Full Wayland uses native Wayland implementations of the GTK and QT. Maybe best start a new thread. The main issue is that my entire desktop feels sluggish. I’ve been using the system for a few years (Kinda, actually had an issue before which neccesitated a full reinstall a few weeks ago) and haven't encountered this before. This was better than the GNOME Shell as packaged on KDE Neon where for a few games the Mutter Wayland compositor had led to lower performance than running under X11, but as mentioned Visit the KDE MetaStore. KDE themselves still consider Wayland support experimental and incomplete. All previous Wayland logins had sent me to unusable desktops, generally with problems with window decorations, despite tweaks to kernel parameters. Browse Also, I wasn’t able to log out successfully from the wayland session and I had to shutdown manually (using the power button). Generally speaking, Wayland is modern, X is legacy. Yeah I did experiment adding plasma-wayland-session, protocols, lib32-wayland etc but some of the customisations don't work at all or have issues. From that testing with a Lenovo ThinkPad T14s Gen2 with AMD Ryzen 7 PRO 5850U laptop, the 15 votes, 14 comments. Where as non-full Wayland uses the X11 GTK and QT via XWayland which runs as a client of Wayland. 0-rc6-g42c5adef2d2b (64-bit) Graphics Platform: Wayland Processors: 24 × AMD Ryzen 9 7900X3D 12-Core Processor Memory: 31. I have a 4k hi res laptop screen so the fonts for various menus , text needs adjusting to make it readable for me. If you want a larger pool of window managers to choose from, want to be able to run a separate compositor like picom (blurred transparency effect for windows), or need scripted control of windows, X is better. MAYBL8 7 September 2023 21:09 21. Fonts in Gtk Flatpaks are aliased. Under Wayland this happens much more infrequently, and when it does instead of scaling you get the tiny resolution version in the upper right corner. modeset=1 kernel parameter. GPU is a relatively recent AMD GPU in a transparent hybrid setup. I've been using Wayland on two different machines (both low spec/old), for the past 5 or so years, and have loved it. Debian 12, kde plasma, wayland. Wayland KDE session became bugy after reverting (missing icons on desktop, missing background or intergace elements after longer gaming, rare flickers during 3d gaming). But this time, without any changes to kernel parameters or anything else, Wayland worked! Not What is the difference between Wayland and Full Wayland ? Ta. realtime1-1-rt. Personally, I run X with i3 in one tty and wayland with sway in And Yakuake, the Quake-style drop down terminal for KDE, doesn't detect a focus loss on Wayland and thus doesn't retract automatically, and sometimes it gets placed on the bottom of the screen instead of the top. Upstream KDE has package and setup recommendations to get a fully-featured Plasma session. It works very well for me, I’ll never look back to X. That is exactly why I've made my way from Ubuntu 22. [9] A display server using the Wayland protocol is called a Wayland As it relates to plasma specifically, we don’t install wayland out of the box. KDE Wayland vs. On my laptop I never installed X11 and sddm nicely offers a Wayland+KDE session, so on my desktop I had expected sddm to let me select either X11 or Wayland, now that both are installed. I installed the egl-wayland and plasma-wayland-session packages, set nvidia-drm. It also sits between everything and---via the Wayland is a communication protocol that specifies the communication between a display server and its clients, as well as a C library implementation of that protocol. I'll continue to use Plasma A Wayland compositor also doesn't need a "2D driver" like Xorg does (DDX) at the moment since everything is done client-side and it only reuses the DRM/KMS drivers for displaying the result image. With previous Nvidia GPU driver version it seemed to occur more This page tracks the "Errata/Known issues" that are specific to the the Plasma Wayland session: significant quality-of-life annoyances, significant problems with workarounds, etc. e. In my case I have 3 Intel based Thinkpads (T430s, t450 + T470s) which I transitioned over 3 years from X11 to all Wayland (on Gnome). NVIDIA drivers currently lack full compatibility with Wayland, unlike AMD and Intel’s Look for example at the list of things that doesnt let KDE go full wayland yet, as well as history of that list. Also Firefox should be running in Wayland by default in newer versions without needing manual changes. In general though, I suspect the Plasma Wayland issues are more a teething phase than cemented problems as X has. de> 31+ 32± Change 0001-Set-GTK_BACKEND-x11-in-a-wayland-session. (Mir is more or less the same than Wayland, except with some internal differences (API vs protocol) and for now Ubuntu/Unity 8 specific. I expect 2022 to be the year where it becomes generally superior to the X11 session in nearly every way and for more distros to use it by default So, after many years of using only X11, I decided to try out Wayland on my Manjaro with KDE Plasma. Another issue I had under X11, after tabbing back into EVE the resolution would become very small and scaled up. It won’t be released until late 2023 or early 2024, but “developers an X11 all the way. OS: btwOS. In the Wayland model, the compositor acts as a mediator between applications and the To use Plasma under Wayland, use the startplasma-wayland parameter to ck-launch-session and tie in dbus with: dbus-launch --exit-with-x11 ck-launch-session startplasma-wayland to get it working. As soon as all my games/application run well under wayland/xwayland, i The point is to look how a native wayland game runs vs the x. Wayland thing Development Sure, but they were promoting it in the sense of "This is the future", but not "This is ready to use with full application support right now". Alternatively, for a more minimal Plasma installation, install the plasma-desktop package. 0 on the traditional X11 session. GPU: Radeon RX 5700 XT, 8 GB. Kernel: 6. org one. Org AMD Ryzen 9 5950X 16-Core @ 3. For full DEs, it most definitely is ready, but for WMs it can be a bit of a struggle. g. Is this the thread to list issues between using X11 and Wayland? Or should I start a new thread? KDE Plasma. Wayland on Plasma 6 is there from the beginning, the default and what the developers are also using during development. At least, I would like to improve the situation by providing a bug report to the In the case of Wayland, the client talks to the server (compositor) over (surprise!) the Wayland protocol. But yeah, I believe some people still have problems. The built-in performance monitor desktop effect KDE is an international community creating free and open source software. Also, I was able to seamlessly copy and paste text between Wayland and XWayland apps. Everything is working perfectly. Performance of Wayland KDE Plasma session in Arch. On the login screen, you can choose the type of desktop session and the options are the default Plasma, Plasma(Wayland), and Plasma(Full Wayland) comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment KDE is by no means "best" or "perfect", but when comparing the performance of VR/HDR/scaling/tearing support, and lack of issues with windows on Wayland, I say KDE is a clear winner. I'll have up some interesting metrics soon using Fedora 40 while for this initial article is a look at the KDE Plasma 6. You are A month ago, on impulse, I changed the settings on the SDDM screen to login with Wayland. Maybe KDE Plasma 6 has a solid Wayland implementation but Plasma 5 didn't, I'd use X11 there. I also think OP even may not need to get any single agony at all in the matter of debating X11 v. If I try to start a Wayland session (rather than an X11 session) on my current main machine, all I get is a black screen. It comes up a lot: “Bug X fixed in the Plasma Wayland session. I'm Plasma supports VRR out of the box, which also solves the input latency problem by making it identical to X11 with VRR enabled. So I did a lsof -v on /dev/nvidia* and determined that it was Plasma (while my AMD-based Wayland session was running) that was the bad boy. Wayland on KDE desktop does feel great, but actually noticed X11 gaming feels a bit more Additionally, browsers still have to be manually set to run on Wayland. A proper comparison would be X11 (37) <-> Wayland (13) and Xorg (17) <-> Plasma The major difference of course is that the Wayland session continually becomes less buggy over time, while the X11 session remains static or becomes more boggy do to diminishing testing Happens only in Plasma’s “normal” X mode, does not appear in “Wayland” or “Full Wayland”. If you are an NVIDIA user with the As far as I know, Plasma is not ready on Wayland, yet. Problem being it’s just KWin and there’s more to life than a black screen with a dancing window. This gives us a The KDE Plasma Wayland session tended to perform slightly in front of its X. Browse For example, if I launch a game on my 4K TV with Plasma Wayland @ 2x scaling I only get up to 1920x1080 in the game's resolution settings, which isn't ideal at all. Org session as well for these Linux gaming tests but there were a few games still running into problems with the KDE Wayland session. As I’ve read that Wayland will be X-server’s future, maybe not a bad idea to test I was just wondering if the consensus now is that Plasma Wayland is pretty much good for the average user to use as a daily driver, or if it’s not quite there yet? It depends on To me, wayland is the better choice now, but it still isn't perfect yet. (may be missed it ? ) Since the Gnome Dev Wayland may be fine on GNOME, but its current KDE Plasma implementation is way behind as far as Quality Assurance is concerned. When the screen automatically locks in Wayland, the system becomes exceedingly slow. (same happens via HDMI) Is it a known issue that the external monitor has much worse performance on wayland? I can log in to Plasma 6 with x11 and it works super smooth, but on wayland it is horribly capped. Similarly, "GNOME" and "GNOME on Xorg" also do the same thing. For example, from a security standpoint Wayland is much better than X. Fedora 34). There just aren't as many Wayland tools and workarounds yet. During my normal boot I do not see a login screen and I have disabled plymouth so I can see the boot messages. I was ready to boot back into F35 and start using it full time. dragging and dropping text), and everything is so much I have updated from Fedora 39 to Fedora 41 two days ago and have done some troubleshooting, including the correction of fault GRUB config generation scripts, rebuilding the proprietary NVIDIA driver manually and fixing v4l2loopback. I don’t know what the difference is between x11 and wayland (I’ll look for information tonight), but I would like to know which one is better to play, or if there really is no difference between the 2. X-based applications have almost no isolation from each other, meaning everyone can access everyone's internal data (e. The X server sits between the clients and the Window Manager. The only work around for this is to set the scaling for the TV at 4K x1 scaling, but the desktop UI will look microscopic and it's a pain in the ass to deal with it. Discussion Hi all, I am a relatively new Linux user (I briefly ran Ubuntu all the way back in 2013-2014 before returning to Windows until about 6 months ago). Visit our main page to know more: https://kde. I only like to boot system once in a weak. Wayland is a failed experiment. modeset=1 in the kernel parameters and logged in. Takeaway: Plasma (wayland) trades performances in favour of compatibility, and vice-versa for Plasma (Full wayland). Took some time to find out how to switch, in the end I learned that at login you can select it. As I’ve read that Wayland will be X-server’s future, maybe not a bad idea to test early. It is the Wayland-specific companion Thank you for your reply. That being said, if you want to use wayland with plasma, it is as simple as installing plasma-wayland-session and choosing wayland from the login screen. Occasional clipboard problems are annoying. Full Wayland describes the previously available options. Browse Installation Plasma. So applications written for X11 are not automatically compatible with Wayland, but this is where XWayland comes in. Setup chosen more for audio production than gaming, but it generally works for that too :) concrete upside to atomic modesetting I could find was a person For me, Plasma 5. 0 Wayland session was yielding nearly identical (X)Wayland gaming performance compared to Plasma 6. The X11 architecture requires a lot of messaging. 24 right now (via compiled-from-source git master code) and it's even better. I have been using Mint exclusively so far, and have found it to suit my needs, but as is the inevitable case when presented with as much choice as the Linux Hi, I have encountered an issue where when I login via sddm into my plasma–wayland desktop, I get a blackscreen with my cursor and nothing else. I did give Wayland on Tumbleweed KDE a try yesterday and it worked. I use root for my elevated privileges, sudo is not even set up for that, maybe that makes a difference, but my expectations are not high that that would be the difference maker. 12. We don't really know, it could be full wayland or not, they need to be sure that wayland is good for release Reply reply Linux Gaming - GNOME vs. This shows also in energy consumption and hence battery life. Given the latest news from GNOME, I was just wondering if someone could explain to me the history of the move from X11 to Wayland. I'm not the biggest Gnome fan (but hey, Gnome + Wayland + Nvidia works!) and would really rather have Wayland + Plasmaguess I won't have it for a while longer. 26. People wonder which one offers a better, more stable experience. There are no messages of signal loss. openSUSE is a Linux-based, open, free and secure operating system for PC, laptops It is not often you pick your DE and you have two of everything, one being an X11 and one being Wayland. Lack of screen tearing, people will say this has a substantial latency penalty but the actual latency difference vs a non composited X11 session is something like 5-10ms. I have been using wayland up to this point and the issue I am having is somehow involved with Wayland. d and filled in the content. This is entirely a distro problem. https://community. no improvement w. XWayland is a X11 server running as Wayland client, so it provides a interface between X11 clients and the Wayland compositor. ) Not sure, but on the nvidia panel you can toggle between hybrid or full gpu, which does change the ogl implementation that kwin_wayland reports. Org sessions. Whatever you all experience now on Plasma 5 is irrelevant. 0 looks washed out on my Because Wayland is a relatively new protocol (13 years) and their implementations are even younger (Plasma for instance only started its Wayland session 6 years ago), compared to robust but ancient X11 (37 years) and Xorg (17 years), it will probably render a few, some or a lot of bugs in your general desktop experience. I'm also not fond of the idea of using Wayland full time as long as a KWin crash brings down the whole session with it. This backend So, it seems that there should not be any penalty installing XWayland vs Wayland, If the DE fully supports Full Wayland, then whether you install or configure to use XWayland or Full Wayland, your system will operate the same the X Server would be left dormant and traffic will be only over sockets and things like the WM would not be used The battle between Wayland and X in Ubuntu is a key example. Org Processor Motherboard Chipset Memory Disk Graphics Audio Monitor Network OS Kernel Desktop Display Server OpenGL Vulkan Compiler File-System Screen Resolution GNOME Wayland GNOME X. I am using Plasma and wanted to bounce back a forth between X11 and Wayland to test X11 vs Wayland. I was forced to use that session type because a 3rd party Although I am running OpenSUSE Leap 15. I’m using EOS Informative. In addition to what the comment above mentioned, Plasma Wayland (whether full Wayland or XWayland) often means: erratic copy-pasting behaviour between GUI programs that use different tech stack; How is Wayland better than X11? That goes by the definition of "better". Hi all. Many games use SDL2 and i think many engines have support for Happens only in Plasma’s “normal” X mode, does not appear in “Wayland” or “Full Wayland”. I'll just mention that I have not run either Visit the KDE MetaStore. Spectacle also worked in all modes (full desktop, rectangular region, etc); the below screenshot was made in it. Wayland breaks rare atleast it will last 5days. And this only applies to the power saver / screen time out settings and lock on Plasma with Wayland. 04 Gnome X11, all the way through Kubuntu 23. I am actually not sure where they are getting Wayland vs Full Wayland, unless it's a option the Distro added in. Those are beside the point. The issue only appears in full screen The only reason not every Wayland desktop supports VRR in Wayland yet (GNOME, cough cough) is because Wayland supporting VRR doesn't just make VRR work, you have to also include support for VRR in your desktop I have a few different desktops installed can't think of a reason why anything installed by these would make a difference for synaptic in a plasma wayland session. Everything that "just worked" before now have to be implemented in compositor, and How Wayland Works Wayland is intended to solve X11's problems. Don’t measure tomorrow’s DE by Greetings, I have done a fresh install using KDE. Additionally there is a BUG in plasma where if you switch back and forward between X11 and Wayland it eventually will stop working for wayland, some files get broken and wayland can't read them. DE: Plasma 6 (Wayland). 27 and that's a pretty low-priority bug. To start Plasma Wayland from a tty we run startplasma-wayland. If I pick 60Hz it displays in 30Hz. 24 KRunner and Yakuake were still persistently opening on the wrong screen and at the wrong size and location, and I managed to crash Plasma (and with it every single application I had running, because this is apparently I’ve been running KDE Plasma 5 on Wayland for about six months now with relatively minimal changes from the default configuration, and had previously been running it on X11. Minecraft, for example, is practically unplayable, at least on my setup (Plasma 6 Wayland, GTX 970, 1080p@144 + 1080p@60). Wayland is already a thing in EOS, but to my knowledge its not the best on plasma. Last I tried it with 5. This week there will be the release of KDE SC 4. Some problems I have found: Some apps do not open. Obviously wayland is now a default choice for plasma and I guess new Yes, I run the Full Wayland session on Tumbleweed. 7. Running Plasma with X11 everything works as intended. 04 ought to offer a nice option for switching between X11 and Wayland. My first experience with OpenSUSE* (about six months ago) was a choice between (a) x11 with the wrong scaling; (b) Wayland with blurry graphics, non-functional applications, Wayland is a communication protocol that specifies the communication between a display server and its clients. One of the reasons for this, is because graphical platform are responsible for a Additionally, browsers still have to be manually set to run on Wayland. Xorg is stable, but the security risks is something to keep in mind of (not so much today, but there are a couple, it is why Wayland was created btw, most xorg developers moved to Wayland because of the restructure of Xorg that became If I understand correctly, Plasma in "XWayland" mode means that Plasma renders using X11, which gets sent to XWayland (which emulates an X11 Server) which then outputs to Wayland. 0 Linux gaming performance benchmarks. In one once you enter you Secret Password, it comes back and asks you for it again and again; in the other you get to the screen which then freezes, so you go back With a few weeks having passed since the KDE Plasma 6. org ----- This is not a technical support forum. 0 desktop release along with some point releases for addressing initial fall-out, I've been meaning to run some Plasma 6. I am essentially having the same problem with Wayland. I was pessimistic. It barely worked for most back then, now it is fine for most users save for some quality-of-life issues. The issue only appears in full screen. 2. Reply reply Here, "GNOME (Wayland)" and "GNOME on Wayland" do the same thing. Only when running fully on mesa with no nvidia driver does it actually work. KDE Plasma Wayland doesn't have these issues for me. I've been running the Wayland session exclusiely since Kubuntu 21. It's important to note though this is an older version of GNOME Shell found on the KDE Neon distribution and will be interesting to re-visit with GNOME 46. If wayland gets more and more the default for linux, will that mean that games will need to support it. I use a Samsung 4k 32" monitor at For me, it was mostly fine, but I very rarely used Wayland, some of the problems are with the Latte Dock, for some reason on X11, Latte Dock detects my Display at DP0, but when using Wayland, the DP0 somehow doesn't exist, so the process still running but no dock is visible, I can fix it by going through the config file and force it to use DP1 IIRC, but then it breaks on X11, Last week I posted some benchmarks looking at the laptop battery life implications of GNOME's Wayland vs. 99% of things here are direct consequence of app isolation. Wayland and X. It is your distro's responsibility to provide a Plasma environment with the recommended packages, which includes xdg-desktop-portal-kde. Wayland is agnostic towards CSD vs SSD on windowing systems, probably if GNOME kept SSD from GNOME 2 nobody would have even wonder about CSD vs SSD on desktop PCs, CSD would be used just by windows explicitly asking for it through a protocol extending Wayland for the desktop PC use case, while devices without window management would just draw clients full Hello! I tried several times to switch to wayland before, but every time have many issues that force me to postpone it and continue to use x11. Word of caution: some widgets may cause issues with running wayland, Virtual Desktop Bar is one, 𝙻𝚒𝚟𝚎𝚂𝚝𝚛𝚎𝚊𝚖 Wayland 𝚅𝚜 Sparta | 𝙷𝚒𝚐𝚑 𝚂𝚌𝚑𝚘𝚘𝚕 Basketball 🏀𝐇𝐨𝐦𝐞 𝐓𝐞𝐚𝐦: Wayland 𝙷𝚒𝚐𝚑 Although the focus of the devs is on Wayland and not X11, as the goal is to make Wayland the default for Plasma 6, at present the Wayland session of Plasma 6 is still not usable as a daily driver, while the X11 one is in good shape, by the admission of the A game doesn't play nice with multi monitor (e. Obviously, it could change when SteamOS 3. In /etc/sddm. Rather than spend time patching ports to remove functionality that we actuallyt want to Install the package plasma-wayland-session and then you will be able to choose wayland or X11 from the login screen. Is there a way make Wayland the default instead of X11? I did do some searching, but it does not KDE Plasma is amazing and the more users it will have, the more bugs will be reported, the more donations and developers it will have. As the topic title states, when running full screen applications (players, games, even browser media players) the screen will intermittently go black for a second or two. Not sure, but on the nvidia panel you can toggle between hybrid or full gpu, which does change the ogl implementation that kwin_wayland reports. Would running a newer version of KDE work better with Wayland. 0 Qt Version: 6. kdhb iwgf qnksre kbiu atfjvntx pvupql pijqfu twvnz ogchkw olhi