Comfyui vs a1111. I have Automatic1111 installed.

Comfyui vs a1111 A good point you brought up is that A1111 only gets easier through video guides, and that's one of the biggest things ComfyUI is missing. 3 Analyzing Results; Checking Speed Performance 3. Usage: python3 comfyui_a1111_prompt_array_generator. For anything I feel is missing or could be improved, I can either use a Comfy workflow or develop a Simple tab workflow. to calls comparing to Forge. 3 Comfy UI; SD Next vs Automatic 1111; Conclusion; FAQ; Article Introduction. example file in the corresponding ComfyUI installation directory. Question - Help I just decided to try out Fooocus after using A1111 since I started, and right out of the box the speed increase using SDXL models is massive. I'll probably stick to ComfyUI from here on out, unless A1111 gets some crazy feature that ComfyUI doesn't have. Each generation differs by at most 1 second, which might as well just be run to run variances. It aims to provide user a more convinient way to make prompts for Text2Image model which is trained on Saved searches Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly I am completely new to this and wondering what the difference between A1111, controlNet, and comfyUI are? I know comfyUI and A1111 are GUIs but is there any significant difference between all three. “(Composition) will be different between comfyui and a1111 due to various reasons”. some days I would get lucky with 1024by1024, some days even 1024 by 1024 won't work. google. fix. com/file/d/1iUPtXtAUilKc7 Never said A1111 had good UX/UI, I just said it's a lot more intuitive than ComfyUI. I have Automatic1111 installed. once you get comfy with comfy you don't want to go back. A non-destructive workflow is a workflow where you can reverse and redo something earlier in the pipeline after working on later steps. So you workflow should look like this: KSampler (1) -> VAE Decode -> Upscale Image (using Model) -> Upscale Image By (to downscale the 4x result to desired size) -> VAE Encode -> KSampler (2) I am currently setup on MacBook Pro M2, 16gb unified memory. despite the complex look, it's The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. 00it/s with ComfyUI. What I would like to do is just simply replicate the With the latest update to ComfyUI it is now possible to use the AdvancedClipEncode node which gives you control over how you want prompt weights interpreted and normalized. Please share your tips, tricks, and workflows for using this software to create A1111 made machines vulnerable by allowing people to save images wherever they likes, and also loading images from specific locations as code. Introduction; Test Setup; Performance Comparison 3. Pop!_OS is an operating system for STEM and creative professionals who use their computer as a tool to discover and create. While testing Comfy, I can't manage to recreate the image created by a1111 despite setting the exact same values (I used the Load button in Comfy to interpret the workflow). It's a matter of using different things like ControlNet, regional prompting, IP-Adapters, IC-Light, so on and so forth, together to create interesting images that you like. This allows to create ComfyUI nodes that interact directly with some parts of the webui's normal pipeline. A1111 or ComfyUI I was facing similar issues when i first started using ComfyUI, try adjusting CFG scale to 5 and if your prompts are big like in A1111, add a token merging node. 2 Testing Different Sampling Methods; 2. There is no tiling in the default A1111 hires. It says something like this "prompt executed in xx seconds". And above all, BE NICE. 0 RC adding DoRA support, it seems like using DoRA will be much easier. For a I've moved from A1111 to ComfyUI, but one thing I'm really missing is the Restart sampler found in A1111. Welcome to the unofficial ComfyUI subreddit. This seemed true for even the 2% (figurative, not literal) power users much less the 98% (again, example value to . I had to reinstall it so many times and watch so many YT videos dedicated to A1111 issues. haven't had much luck with a1111 with sdxl. It offers more control over the image generation process than Automatic1111, making it a better choice for advanced users who want to fine-tune the model parameters and create complex workflows. and nothing gets close to comfyui here. if I need a few ideas. Why is there such big speed differences when generating between ComfyUI, Automatic1111 and other solutions? And why is it so different for each GPU? A friend of mine for example is doing this on a GTX 960 (what a madman) and he's experiencing up to 3 times the speed when doing inference in ComfyUI over Automatic's. 2), brown eyes, no makeup, instagram, around him are other people playing volleyball, intricate, highly detailed, extremely nice flowing, real loving, generous, elegant, color rich, HDR, 8k UHD, 35mm lense, Nikon Z7 #stablediffusionart #stablediffusion #stablediffusionai In this Video I have compared Automatic1111 and ComfyUI with different samplers and Different Steps. 0 for all tests] -Misc obs (probably the most interesting part of this post) With the A1111 1. 9000calls vs 1900 calls. A1111 is REALLY unstable compared to ComfyUI. For this, we simply need to copy the “extra_models_path. The most powerful and modular diffusion model GUI, api and backend with a graph/nodes interface. Generating noise on the GPU vs CPU does not affect performance in any way. Aug 11, 2024 · Here's a comparison chart between ComfyUI, A1111 (Stable Diffusion Web UI), and Forge, highlighting key features, strengths, and considerations: Feature ComfyUI 3 days ago · AUTOMATIC1111 (often shortened to A1111) and ComfyUI are two popular open source web UIs for Stable Diffusion. I would like to see some nice features from Foocus to be implemented into Forge web UI, like ready styles, The best ComfyUI alternatives are A1111 Stable Diffusion WEB UI, InvokeAI and stability matrix. I admit that I don't understand the meaning of the CLIP Set Last Layer value which in between do the same thing with a latent upscaler. My A1111 stalls when I press generate for most SDXL models, but Fooocus pumps a 1024x1024 out in seconds. yaml instead of . I usually get around 1. If you want to use RealESRGAN_x4plus_anime_6B you need work in pixel space and forget any latent upscale. Especially a1111, since I'll be working with that the most. Asked reddit wtf is going on everyone blindly copy pasted the same thing over and over. 5 though. A1111 sketch was quite buggy too but in Forge when sketching on a bigger image the mouse would disappear after drawing a line and only appear a few seconds later so you can draw the next line which is quite annoying. example” file and rename it to simply “extra_models_path. I am a big fan of both A1111 and ComfyUI. Its image compostion capabilities allow you to assign different prompts and weights, even using different models, to specific areas of an image. It is a node based system so you have to build your workflows. If you just want to make images and see results In our simple benchmark test, Comfy UI showed impressive speed and outperformed both Automatic 1111 and Invoke AI. E. ComfyUI: At the other end of the spectrum is the increasingly popular ComfyUI tool for image generation. I'm trying to rebuild 1:1 the basic setup of A1111 in comfyui to achieve the exact same image using the same seed. Nov 7, 2023 · You probably applied prompt weighting same as A1111. You probably applied prompt weighting same as A1111. DiffusionEngine (for SDXL) + Unet Patcher (include patches from A1111, comfyui, and Forge, customized for webui use cases) + memory management system almost same as comfyui but In A1111, the Regional Prompter plug-in can perform these same functions. (by comfyanonymous) stable-diffusion Pytorch. . json to ComfyUI Advanced usage: Use CTRL+Drag to select multiple nodes and then CTRL+C to copy the workflow block. 5) and sgm. They had discoverable unique IDs on a proxy, provided graciously for your convenience, which led to an expectation-of-privacy issue, not an authentication or authorization Hello! Looking to dive into animatediff and am looking to learn from the mistakes of those that walked the path before me🫡🙌🫡🙌🫡🙌🫡🙌 Are people using This document presents some old and new workflows for promptless inpaiting in Automatic1111 and ComfyUI and compares them in various scenarios. In this case the developer explains that they wanted to build Forge as an extension to A1111, but due to some technical issues, it was easier to bundle A1111 inside the Forge, than to Better is subjective. g. Reply reply oO0_ • if you dislike slow, full of megabytes of java script web pages, and dont like to make 5 clicks (like in yt to switch language) where 2 is enough - install ComfyUI and forgot 1111 as unlucky prompt. safetensors file, models and VAEs in the proper folders and Comfy correctly found them all. I play with ComfyUI for new things, even though a node-based workflow is not my personal choice. When convert to ComfyUI, you should Compare ComfyUI vs a1111-nevysha-comfy-ui and see what are their differences. Recent commits have higher weight than older ones. I am happy with Foocus and Forge web UI. everything ai is changing left and right, so a flexible approach is the best imho. I haven't found easy methods to replicate stuff like that in Introduction AnimateDiff in ComfyUI is an amazing way to generate AI Videos. Please share your tips, tricks, and workflows for using this software to create your AI art. Hey all, I was getting some odd differences between between A1111 and Comfy for the same t2i settings [Note: No refiner in any of the ComfyUI runs, 30 steps DPM2M++Karras Base SD XL 1. Invoke AI also delivered noteworthy speed improvements over Discover the differences in stability, speed, and image quality between Stable Diffusion Automatic1111 and ComfyUI in this detailed comparison by Alfamix. r/pop_os. 2) (best:1. 1 Automatic 1111; 3. A quality/performance comparison of the Fooocus image generation software vs Automatic1111 and ComfyUI. Pay attention to the Batch sizes, and I'll explain a bit here:. While ComfyUI and A1111 have their strengths, Forge emerged as the best choice for me. I do have the easynegative. My guess -- and it's purely a guess -- is that ComfyUI wasn't using the best cross-attention optimization. The more complex the workflows get (e. With ComfyUI you just download the portable zip file, unzip it and get ComfyUI running instantly, even a kid can get ComfyUI installed. I'm unsure if setting A1111 Emphasis mode (in Settings - Stable Diffusion) to 'No Norm' will fix this, but seems worth a try. I'm wondering, is there an easy way to train DoRA at the moment, and has anyone made comparisons between the two techniques? Share Add a Configuring the Text2Image. A1111 is different from ComfyUI in that ComfyUI considers the entire process as one Batch Counts. yaml”. After more testing, I had found that after 75 characters in the prompt which also the clip limit. works great for 1. The guides that are out there for ComfyUI are either cryptic or I switched to ComyfUI from A1111 last year and haven't looked back, in fact I can't remember the last time I used A1111. It offers more flexibility and control than Automatic1111, making it a better choice for advanced Nov 7, 2023 · I consistently get much better results with Automatic1111's webUI compared to ComfyUI even for seemingly identical workflows. 4) girl. 2 Invoke AI; 3. Notice the flip from s/it to it/s. I really like the extensions library and ecosystem that already exists around A1111- in particular stuff like 'OneButtonPrompt' which is great for inspiration on styles, etc. It is true that A1111 and ComfyUI weight the prompts differently. Perhaps, if I improve my prompt game, I could get results as good as fooocus-MRE with a1111 and/or comfyUI - so I'd like to improve these tools' performance. Stars - the number of stars that a project has on GitHub. In this article, we will be comparing the speed and performance of Comfy UI, Automatic 1111, and Invoke AI. A lot of people are just discovering this technology, and want to show off what they created. This can be a good indicator that A1111 is doing extra function calls, and having sd-webui-comfyui is an extension for A1111 webui that embeds ComfyUI workflows in different sections of the normal pipeline of the webui. It’s like Vlad vs A1111 all over again. Reply reply Generating noise on the GPU vs CPU does not affect performance in any way. Also, while ComfyUI is very powerful and flexible, most of what I usually want to do seems a lot more convenient and straightforward in A1111 The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. Trace file size is also different. How to link Stable Diffusion Models Between ComfyUI and A1111 or Other Stable Diffusion AI image generator WebUI? Whether you are using a third-party installation package or the official integrated package, you can find the extra_model_paths. (by When using ComfyUI and Automatic1111 WebUI (A1111), you might notice that even with the same seed value, the generated images differ. I want to know if using ComfyUI: The performance is better? The image size can be larger? How can UI make a difference in speed, mem usage? Are workflows like mov2mov, infizoom possible in Nice simple and so far clean inpainting results. A1111 Stable Diffusion Prompt for Facial Visuals comments. It lacks some features of A1111, but it is much easier to install and use, and it has a While ComfyUI can help with complicated things that would be a hassle to use with A1111, it won't make your images non-bland. Introduction; testing UI Stability 2. Among other things this gives you the option to interpret the prompt weights the same way A1111 does things (something that seemed to be a popular request). messing around with upscale by model is pointless for high res fix. This means you do need a greater understanding of how Stable Diffusion works, but once you have that, it becomes more I just set up ComfyUI on my new PC this weekend, it was extremely easy, just follow the instructions on github for linking your models directory from A1111; it’s literally as simple as pasting the directory into the extra_model_paths. The a1111 ui is actually doing something like (but across all the tokens): Forge backend = A1111’s sampling + A1111’s text encoder (clip, emphasize, prompt scheduling, etc) + A1111’s Stable Diffusion Object ldm. ComfyUI. 9. The a1111 ui is actually doing something like (but across all the tokens): This was detailed in another thread where virtually almost no one could provide a reason (in a thread about ComfyUI's advantages over A1111 if they were to consider swapping) that actually mattered and wasn't some absurd irrelevant nonsense to pick it over A1111. 30s/it with A1111 (1 picture @ 768x512) but I'll regularly get 1. I've been using A1111 for over a year now and I've never seen it flip to it/s. That's why new fresh forgeUi made so ComfyUI vs Automatic1111 (A1111) ComfyUI and Automatic1111 (sometimes also called A1111 or stable-diffusion-webui) are the two most popular Stable Diffusion UIs, and they both have their strengths and weaknesses. Both allow you to interactively develop image generation pipelines, so which one should you use? Jan 24, 2024 · ComfyUI 和 Stable Diffusion WebUI 都是基于 Stable Diffusion的。 有的同学可能会同时安装这两个工具，它们使用的模型其实都是一样的，但是模型的目录组织方式不同，如果每个模型都部署两份，很浪费硬盘空间。 ComfyUI is a user interface (UI) for generating text-to-image art using Stable Diffusion models. A1111 breaks a lot and its so annoying to fix it. 1 Comparing Sampling Steps; 3. A1111 has almost 5x aten. Since the backend is ComfyUI, everything runs fast and efficiently. Generated in Fooocus with JuggernautXL8 and then upscaled in With A1111, you can easily page through a batch of them. A1111 normalizes the weights while ComfyUI doesn't. A lot of it already exists in A1111. I need to use windows for gaming and adobe software, so I passthrough my NVIDIA; this Saved searches Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly Having said that, I do think people who are really attached to A1111 and take a look at comfyui and get scared would be very surprised if they took more than a minute to really examine it and play with it. If you watch a lot of Stable Diffusion videos like me, I’ve seen many YouTubers shifting from A1111 to ComfyUI as it supports a deeper set of customizations with custom nodes from the community. Edit #1: I think I get what happened to me. yaml. In ComfyUI the prompt strengths are also more sensitive because they are not normalized. ComfyUI is the main alternative to A1111. If you want a better grounding at making your own comfyUI systems consider checking out my tutorials. I am still unsure what controlNet is for but I see multiple vid2vids on YT using it with other stuff and just curious if anyone can fill me in on what it is. I have yet to find anything that I could do in A1111 that I can't do in ComfyUI including XYZ Plots. In ComfyUI you can see the seconds that took to execute the whole workflow in the console. example (text) file, then saving it as . Belittling their efforts will get you banned. Here's the thing, ComfyUI is very intimidating at first so I completely understand why people are put off by it. A1111 does a lot behind the scenes with prompts, while ComfyUI Doesn't, This is why ComfyUI is the BEST UI for Stable Diffusion#### Links from the Video ####Olivio ComfyUI Workflows: https://drive. Growth - month over month growth in stars. 2 Impact of Streaming/Recording Software; Tested failed loras with a1111 they were great. example. This is primarily due to two key factors: noise ComfyUI and Automatic1111 (sometimes also called A1111 or stable-diffusion-webui) are the two most popular Stable Diffusion UIs, and they both have their strengths and weaknesses. ; In A1111, it will be based on the Number DanTagGen(Danbooru Tag Generator) is a LLM model designed for generating Danboou Tags with provided informations. and don't get scared by the noodle forests you see on some screenshots. However, the ComfyUI developers have taken this into account and made it much easier to use your current models in the Automatic1111 interface without having to copy or move them between folders. I found ComfyUI_restart_sampling custom node, but it's a bit more complicated. 1 Setting up both UI Versions; 2. I just set up ComfyUI on my new PC this weekend, it was extremely easy, just follow the instructions on github for linking your models directory from A1111; it’s literally as simple as pasting the directory into the extra_model_paths. Also, it's not about the time only, look how much resources uses one and the other for complete the same task. Only arguments I used in A1111 were --xformers. Please suggest which GUI will be best for my usecase. For instance, is controlnet ran before or after the upscaler? i started with invokeai, but have mostly moved to A1111 because of the plugins as well as a lot of youtube video instructions specifically referencing features in A1111. you define the complexity of what you build. The path is as follows: Automatic1111 is great, but the one that impressed me, in doing things that Automatic1111 can't, is ComfyUI. I'm curious if anyone knows what the order of the rendering is when using A1111 using controlnet. Source Code. Reply reply I have been watching videos on InbokeAI for the last couple of weeks, and it seems to be overall a much more polished version of Automatic1111, which much better inpainting and outpainting, however, it seems to lack X/Y plot which I use pretty much every time to compare results between models, and I heard it might not be compatible with every model out there. invoke has a cleaner UI compared to A1111, and while thats superficial, when demonstrating or explaining concepts to others, A1111 can be daunting to the uninitiated. Gradio caused no vulnerability. If you just want to Some interest findings of A1111 and comfyui. The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. Methods overview "Naive" inpaint: The most basic workflow just masks an area and generates new content for it. Activity is a relative number indicating how actively a project is being developed. I don't know about the UI, in both A1111 and ComfyUI I always look the console. What I really would like to see is a A1111 UI for image generation and then a comfy ui node based The key difference is that if you download an "extension" for A1111, you still need the original A1111. Thanks you for the screenshot Reply reply Fooocus vs ComfyUI vs AUTOMATIC1111 ? Question - Help I am an absolute beginner in photo editing I have used some basic tools in photoshop and generative AI, I don't know which GUI to use, I will be mostly using inpaint, outpaint and text generation. Comparing UI Stability: Automatic1111 Vs ComfyUI Table of Contents. Long story short i noticed either my comfyui or lora settings are not compatible or something. LatentDiffusion (for sd1. For In ComfyUI, use a loadImage node to get the image in and that goes to the openPose control net. same seed probably not nessesary and can cause bad artifacting by the "Burn in" problem when you stack same seed samplers. Then you can use CTRL+V to paste the workflow block to another a1111 is IOS 13 and comfyui is Android 9. A1111 295MB vs Forge 126 MB. The main difference between ComfyUI and Automatic1111 is that Comfy uses a non-destructive workflow. Do they always produce the same image? The answer is no. But it is not the final answer. Because SD does not really work well without a text prompt, the results are usually quite Ultimate Speed Test: ComfyUi vs Invoke ai vs Automatic1111 Table of Contents. prompt: light summer dress, realistic portrait photo of a young man with blonde hair, hair roots slightly faded, russian, light freckles(0. multiple LoRas, negative prompting, upscaling), the Compare ComfyUI vs a1111-nevysha-comfy-ui and see what are their differences. Its user-friendly interface, robust performance, and comprehensive documentation make it a pleasure to use. py <steps> [step_start inclusive (default:0)] [step_end exclusive (default:max)] Load the newly generated workflow. While it’s not perfect, it’s more stable than A1111/Forge. I changed card and should have reinstalled a1111. I have a workflow I could share if you're stuck on how to do that bit. I was tested on A1111 and comfyui to produce similar image before. Our crowd-sourced lists contains more than 10 apps similar to ComfyUI for Windows, Linux, Mac, iPhone and more. As far as I can tell, how prompt weighting is handled is one of the key differences between ComfyUI and A1111 (A1111 does some kind of normalization I think). I have never used that last node before, I love comfyui but I was ready to fire back up A1111 for inpainting as comfy was proving a pain and most workflows for anything img2img are large, complex and focused on hires and upscale or using that vase inpainting node that doe snot work as desired. You don't need to switch to one or the other. And honestly, if nothing else, I’m glad to be done with using a Gradio interface! So, why what is the difference between A1111 and comfy that makes this happen? please note I am a basic user who doesn't use ipadapter or controlnet and I'm well aware comfy is far more flexible, that's not the question being asked. We know A1111 was using xformers, but weren't told, as far as i noticed, what ComfyUI was using. A very short example is that when doing (masterpiece:1. When convert to ComfyUI, you should I love A1111, but there is a huge misconception somewhere in the app that author should look into. It is a good general VAE and VAE's do not make a huge difference overall. Download motion modules (original ones There is a preprocessor (bottom A1111 vs Fooocus speed . The extension itself is not a replacement for A1111. Sponsored by Dola: AI ComfyUI is a powerful and flexible UI for generating text-to-image art. it's the perfect tool to explore generative ai. With ComfyUI, all you get are some medium-sized thumbnails, and the only way to get a good look at them is to open each one in a separate tab. Reply reply D4rK_K1tsune • reddit removes all exif data from uploads The video was pretty interesting, beyond the A1111 vs. A1111 tends to have a very weak effect of prompts compared to ComfyUI, so you must have given strong weighting to match it. Please keep posted images SFW. 3) (quality:1. Why virtualized? My host PC runs arch linux on the mainboard GPU. A1111 almost as same as ComfyUI base only. Comfy speed comparison. Therefore, in ComfyUI, you need to set Batch sizes to be the same as the number of frames read to avoid animation appearing unsmooth. dfpn kdth hsnt klmmm ohrnyi syycd eguapv bpd unvs rnuopcs